Fields and Dennis LLP

  • Our Firm
    • Our Approach and Philosophy
    • News and Media Coverage
  • Attorneys
    • Sheryl J. Dennis
    • Jonathan E. Fields
    • Vicki L. Shemin, J.D., LICSW, ACSW
    • Hugh F. Ferguson, Ph.D.
    • Andrea E. DeLaney
    • Wendie E. Murstein
    • Jonathan Crafts
    • S. Robert Fish, Jr.
    • James E. O’Connell, Jr.
    • Support Staff
      • RIKKI B. SAKSIK
  • Practices
    • Online Divorce Mediations
    • Fledgling Estate Plan for Millennials
    • Family Law
    • Divorce
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Estate Planning
    • Elder Law
    • Guardianship
    • Probate
    • Real Estate Law
    • Civil Litigation
    • Business Litigation
    • White-Collar Criminal & Regulatory Defense and Investigations
    • Mediation
    • Collaborative Law
    • Parent Coordinator
    • Arbitration
  • Resources
    • Covid 19 / Coronavirus Resource Page
    • Fledgling Estate Plan
    • Legal Information
    • Significant Cases
    • Psychology of Divorce
    • Cyber Issues and Divorce
    • Books + Videos
  • Blogs
    • Fields and Dennis LLP Blog
    • Divorce And Mediation Blog
    • Massachusetts Estate Planning Blog
  • Contact
    • Online Consultations & Mediations
    • Map & Directions
    • Pay Invoices Online
    • Contact Us
  • What Others are Saying
  • (781) 489-6776
You are here: Home / Postnup / Prenups & postnups: the dawning of sunrise/sunset clauses

Prenups & postnups: the dawning of sunrise/sunset clauses

by Vicki L. Shemin (as published in the September/October Issue of Massachusetts Lawyers Journal. 

In a recent matter, an interesting dilemma arose.

The parties were negotiating the terms of their prenuptial agreement with assistance
of independent counsel. My client, the bride-to-be (“Elizabeth”), had significantly fewer assets than her fiancé (“Joe”).

During my meeting with Elizabeth, we discussed the pros and cons of a sunset clause — a provision that would render the entire prenup null and void upon the birth of the parties’ first child (or upon
the parties’ adoption of a first child). I encouraged Elizabeth to try to negotiate as many of the terms of the agreement that she felt comfortable so doing with Joe.

The next morning, after Elizabeth and Joe talked it out, the couple was in agreement that the sunset clause was totally appropriate for their life facts and circumstances.

All was well and good, until… Two days later, I received a turnaround draft of the prenup from Joe’s attorney. He had subsequently advised Joe not to include the sunset clause in the prenup. His reasoning
was this: There was no need to include the clause; if Elizabeth and Joe wanted to alter any of the terms of the prenup after the arrival of their child, they could simply amend or revoke the document at that time.

While seemingly perfectly logical on its face, this advice and approach troubled me considerably.

It occurred to me that Elizabeth and Joe would find themselves in the position of essentially negotiating a postnuptial agreement. As with a prenup, one of the most basic tenets of a postnup is that there must be absolutely no evidence of coercion, duress or undue influence.

Coercion. Duress. Undue influence. Those elements can be likened to pornography — different in the eye of the beholder, and yet, you kind of know it when you see it.

Often, when considering whether someone is truly under duress, a judge will attempt to ascertain the emotional state of mind of the spouse who feels she or he was acting out of a loss of fee will. As to coercion and undue influence, the court will look to see if one spouse was directly or tangentially instilling fear in the other to cause him or her to take a certain action. Similarly, undue influence can arise by applying steady pressure on another individual over time or imposing a stronger will
over a weaker person’s will by exploiting a relationship.

Anyone who has experienced parenthood for the first time can attest to the sheer exhaustion, fog and haze that accompanies this time of life. It is hard to imagine that a new parent could be well positioned to negotiate important contract terms while in this state of mind. The carefully considered
decisions and discussions that characterized the prenup period become in sharp contrast to the chaotic and muddled mindset with which one would have to negotiate anew the disposition of significant contract
terms involving key assets and liabilities.

In our case, Elizabeth and Joe gave the matter a great deal of thought and eventually opted for the sunset clause to remain an integral part of their postnup.

So, what is the takeaway lesson? It is clear that any sunset clauses of a prenup — that give rise to renegotiation such that they effectively devolve into a sunrise clause of a postnup — should be generally considered undesirable and approached with all due caution in the light of day.

Vicki L. Shemin, J.D., LICSW, ACSW is a family law attorney, mediator, collaborative lawyer, parenting coordinator and partner at Fields and Dennis LLP. She can be reached at (781) 489-6776, or vshemin@fieldsdennis.com.

Filed Under: Postnup, Prenuptial, Sunrise/Sunset

Contact Us

Phone: 781.489.6776
Fax: 781.489.6233
80 William Street — Suite 210
Wellesley, MA 02481 USA

Recent Posts

Sheryl J. Dennis Quoted in Second Most Read Article in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly

January 3, 2023

Attorney Sheryl Dennis was quoted in Massachusetts Lawyer Weekly’s second most read article of the year. The article discusses the feasibility of remote work from the viewpoint of a number of major law firms in the Boston area. If you are in the office, you are much more invested in the firm and the people […]

Fields and Dennis LLP Fundraiser for K9s for Warriors

December 1, 2022

Over the years Fields and Dennis have been proud to sponsor an annual holiday fundraiser for K9s for Warriors. We will be holding another holiday fundraiser through the end of the year. K9s For Warriors is a program to reduce veteran suicide and help our warriors return to a life of dignity and independence. The […]

Here are 4 Ways Divorced Parents Can Make the Holidays Joyful for Their Children – Attorney Vicki L. Shemin’s Article Featured on Divorcemag.com

November 29, 2022

Just because you and your ex-spouse are no longer together doesn’t mean you can’t co-parent peacefully during the holiday season. There are many ways divorced parents can make the holidays memorable for their children. Read the full article on Divorcemag.com https://www.divorcemag.com/blog/here-are-4-ways-divorced-parents-can-make-the-holidays-joyful-for-their-children

Congratulations to Fields and Dennis LLP Firm members who were selected as Top Lawyers for 2022 by Boston Magazine

November 22, 2022

  Fields and Dennis LLP is proud to congratulate Sheryl Dennis, Vicki L. Shemin and Jonathan Fields on being selected as Top Lawyers for 2022 by Boston Magazine. The Boston Magazine Top Lawyers list is extensively peer-reviewed and curated to bring together the top quality attorneys in Boston, making it easier for anyone seeking an […]

Sheryl J. Dennis Quoted in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly

November 16, 2022

Attorney Sheryl Dennis was quoted in Massachusetts Lawyer Weekly this week. The article discusses the feasibility of remote work from the viewpoint of a number of major law firms in the Boston area. If you are in the office, you are much more invested in the firm and the people around you. It really is […]

Contact Us

Please use the contact form below to email Fields and Dennis LLP.

    Your Name (required)

    Daytime phone (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Brief description of your legal issue:

    Sending a message to Fields and Dennis LLP does not constitute an Attorney Client relationship. Please review our Communication Policy before sending any messages.

    Location

    FIELDS AND DENNIS LLP
    80 William Street — Suite 210
    Wellesley, MA 02481 USA
    (T) 781.489.6776
    (F) 781.489.6233

    You can also find us on…

    Recent Blogs

    • Attorney Jon Fields receives the 2022 John Adams Fiske Award
    • Attorneys Sheryl Dennis and Hugh Ferguson quoted in Newsweek
    • Sheryl J. Dennis Quoted in Second Most Read Article in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly
    • Fields and Dennis LLP Fundraiser for K9s for Warriors
    • Here are 4 Ways Divorced Parents Can Make the Holidays Joyful for Their Children – Attorney Vicki L. Shemin’s Article Featured on Divorcemag.com

    Recent Firm News & Coverage

    • Sheryl J. Dennis Quoted in Second Most Read Article in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly

    • Fields and Dennis LLP Fundraiser for K9s for Warriors

    • Here are 4 Ways Divorced Parents Can Make the Holidays Joyful for Their Children – Attorney Vicki L. Shemin’s Article Featured on Divorcemag.com

    • Congratulations to Fields and Dennis LLP Firm members who were selected as Top Lawyers for 2022 by Boston Magazine

    • Sheryl J. Dennis Quoted in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly

    The Boston metro family law, divorce and estate planning attorneys at the law firm of Fields and Dennis LLP are based in the Newton Wellesley area and serve the city of Newton: Auburndale, Chestnut Hill, Newton Centre, Newton Corner, Newton Upper Falls, Newton Lower Falls, Nonantum, Oak Hill, Waban and West Newton and town of Wellesley: Babson Park, Wellesley Hills, Wellesley Square Fields and Dennis also serves many clients in the Greater Boston and Massachusetts region including Ashland, Dover, Holliston, Medfield, Needham, Sherborn, Westwood, and all of Massachusetts. Attorney Jonathan Fields is a recognized authority on bitcoin and divorce

    Copyright 2021 Fields and Dennis LLP

    Attorneys | Divorce Attorneys | Estate Planning Attorneys | Firm Overview |

    Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Contact | Pay Invoice